| Nate Santoni | 2006 | Lacrosse | Eastern Michigan University | |
| Nyemade Cooper | 2006 | Basketball | Kalamazoo College | 33 |
| Charlotte Spencer | 2006 | Cross Country | Albion College | |
| Gina Gonzales | 2007 | Basketball | College of Mount Saint Mary | 10 |
| Pete Benjamin | 2007 | Lacrosse | Western Michigan University | 39 |
| Ricky Heutter | 2007 | Golf | Warner Southern (FL) | |
| Tim Hughes | 2008 | Water Polo | Western Michigan University | 4 |
| Corinne Kuclo | 2008 | Basketball, Cross Country | Concordia University | |
| Kristen Goncalves | 2008 | Soccer | University of Michigan | 11 |
| Mimi Loveland | 2008 | Basketball | Ave Maria University | 44 |
| Claire McKeone | 2008 | Track and Field | St. Louis | |
| Stacey Szerlag | 2008 | Basketball | Madonna University | 2 |
| Maddy LaFave | 2009 | Cross Country | Schoolcraft College | |
| Susie Pauley | 2009 | Soccer | Xavier University | 20 |
| Joe Berry | 2009 | Lacrosse | Albion College | |
| Nick Forbes | 2009 | Lacrosse | Albion College | 3 |
| Dan Genord | 2009 | Lacrosse | Albion College | 16 |
| Eso Akunne | 2009 | Basketball | University of Michigan | 5 |
| Tim O’Callaghan | 2009 | Baseball | St. Clair County Community College | |
| Katie Weishaar | 2009 | Track and Field | U of D Mercy | |
| Erin Barletta | 2010 | Cheerleading | Hope College | |
| Natalie Clore | 2010 | Cheerleading | Hillsdale College | |
| Brendan Cooper | 2010 | Basketball | Davenport University | |
| Mattie DeDoes | 2010 | Baseball | Oberlin College | |
| Kelsey Geppner | 2010 | Tennis | Denison University | |
| Josh Herbeck | 2010 | Basketball | Westpoint | |
| Matt Jenkins | 2010 | Basketball | Madonna University | |
| Veronica Livingstone | 2010 | Basketball | University of Tiffin | |
| Keith Mackie | 2010 | Basketball | Tiffin State University | |
| Liz Mitchell | 2010 | Basketball | Franciscan University of Stubenville | |
| Lauren Peters | 2010 | Basketball | Ave Maria University | |
| Caitlin Brown | 2011 | Soccer | Iowa | |
| Nate Donnellon | 2011 | Track and Field | University of Kentucky | |
| Nolan Breymaier | 2011 | Baseball | Hillsdale College | |
| Conor Dishman | 2011 | Baseball | Wabash Valley College | |
| Donnie Eaton | 2011 | Baseball | University of Michigan | |
| Jonathan Gragg | 2011 | Crew | University of Kansas | |
| Dennis Olszewski | 2011 | Baseball | Wabash Valley College | |
| Chris Ostrowski | 2011 | Baseball | Mineral Area Jr. College (MO) | |
| Mike Goike | 2011 | Baseball | Concordia University | |
| Matt Wagner | 2011 | Baseball | Butler | |
| Luther Page | 2011 | Basketball | University of Alabama | |
| Darren Washington | 2011 | Basketball | Grand Valley State | |
| Colin McMahon | 2011 | Lacrosse | Kenyon College | |
| Carl Pressprich | 2011 | Lacrosse | Albion College | |
| Stephen Huff | 2011 | Naval ROTC | Eastern Michigan University | |
| Jenna Lanzetta | 2011 | Dance | Western Michigan University | |
| Sarah Falvey | 2012 | Soccer | Air Force Academy | |
| Alicia Curmi | 2012 | Lacrosse | Hope College | |
| Angela Broggi | 2012 | Basketball | Adrian College | |
| Annemarie Fischer | 2012 | Volleyball | Denison University | |
| Taylor Hinkson | 2012 | Basketball | Madonna University | |
| Catherine Doyle | 2012 | Dance | University of Michigan | |
| Aaron Ward | 2012 | Rifle Team | University of Michigan | |
| Adam Kolevar | 2012 | Lacrosse | Otterbein University | |
| Josh Fons | 2012 | Track | University of St. Thomas | |
| Mark Tanski | 2012 | Lacrosse | Adrian College | |
| Aaron Cowhy | 2012 | Baseball | Concordia University | |
| Alex Ziolkowski | 2012 | Lacrosse | University of Dallas | |
| Carrie Wright | 2012 | Soccer | Macalester College | |
| Justin Cooper | 2012 | Soccer | Calvin Coolidge College | |
| Blaise Stearns | 2013 | Football | University of Michigan | |
| Drew Diedrich | 2013 | Football | Cornell University | |
| Joe Kendzicky | 2013 | Football | Hillsdale College | |
| Mason Sarosi | 2013 | Football | Kalamazoo College | |
| Tyler Kirchoff | 2013 | Football | Hope College | |
| Kendric Fowler | 2013 | Football | Sienna Heights | |
| Steve Tracy | 2013 | Football | Mt. Union | |
| Patrick Wolf | 2013 | Football | Hope College | |
| Ashton Hundley | 2013 | Football | Concordia University | |
| Gunnar Gail | 2013 | Baseball | Tiffin University | |
| Carsten Dembeck | 2013 | Baseball | Ashland University | |
| Jack Gage | 2013 | Baseball | Kalamazoo Valley Community College | |
| Joel Parker | 2013 | Baseball | Northwood University | |
| Andrew Martel | 2013 | Golf | Ava Maria University | |
| Austin Hundley | 2013 | Track and Field | Spring Arbor University | |
| Aspen Sims | 2013 | Golf | St. Mary’s College | |
| Malia Gabel | 2013 | Volleyball | Northern Illinois University | |
| Ellery Sarosi | 2013 | Ice Hockey | Wesleyan University | |
| Gabby Gaeta | 2013 | Dance | University of Michigan | |
| Becca Kennelly | 2013 | Dance | University of Detroit-Mercy | |
| Lauren Opplinger | 2013 | Softball | Albion | |
| Lindsay Ulfig | 2014 | Volleyball | Malone University | |
| Paul Galloway | 2014 | Football | Hillsdale College | |
| Kevin Masini | 2014 | Football | Pomona College | |
| Evan Fosha | 2014 | Football | Adrian College | |
| Jason Houle | 2014 | Basketball | West Point | |
| Steven Timm | 2014 | Hockey | Lawrence Technological University | |
| Ryan Baron | 2014 | Hockey | Eastern Michigan University | |
| Rebecca Kukalis | 2014 | Club Lacrosse | University of Toledo | |
| Brittany Layden | 2014 | Club Lacrosse | University of Toledo | |
| Samantha Marsh | 2014 | Club Lacrosse | University of Michigan | |
| Erica Hammerstein | 2014 | Club Lacrosse | University of Michigan | |
| Kora Dreffs | 2014 | Track and Field | Emory University | |
| Andrea Bodary | 2014 | Cross Country and Track | Hillsdale College | |
| DJ Newlin | 2014 | Baseball | Jackson State University | |
| Chris VonKoss | 2020 | Lacrosse | ||
| Riley Cesarini | 2020 | Lacrosse | Ursinus | |
| Matt Montgomery | 2020 | Lacrosse | U Indy | |
| Parker McFarlane | 2020 | Lacrosse | Albion | |
| Chris VonKoss | 2020 | Lacrosse | Dominican University | |
| Brady Karcher | 2020 | Lacrosse | Sienna Heights | |
| Allejandro Rollan | 2020 | Football | Lawrence Tech | |
| Andrew Covert | 2020 | Football | Valparaiso | |
| Brandon Victor | 2020 | Football | ||
| Grace Waldo | 2020 | Ice Hockey | Aquinas | |
| Kim Flaherty | 2020 | Soccer | Aquinas | |
| Kaitlyn Donovan | 2020 | Gymnastics | Illinois State | |
| Emily Graham | 2020 | Volleyball | Illinois Tech | |
| Griffen Kaiser | 2021 | Lacrosse | Milwaukee School of Engineering | |
| Joe Renfer | 2021 | Golf | Adrian College | |
| Savannah Wing | 2021 | Softball | Kent State | |
| Madi Ressler | 2021 | Ice Hockey | Saint Anselm | |
| Jordan Garypie | 2021 | Golf | Embry-Riddle | |
| Rileigh Garbarz | 2021 | Soccer | Saginaw Valley State | |
| Kenny Lashaway | 2021 | Cross Country | Detroit Mercy | |
| Izzie Lashaway | 2021 | Cross Country | Madonna University | |
| George White | 2021 | Sprint Football | WestPoint | |
| Paul Hehmann | 2021 | Football |
